The BOLD Mudhens were eliminated from District 7 play by Eden Valley-Watkins in a wild game that ended with the winning run stranded at 1st base in the bottom of the 7th inning. EV-W outhit BOLD 14-12 and outcored them 13-11. Four unearned runes in the top if the 1st inning proved costly for the Mudhens as they never fully recovered.  They trailed by as many as six runs twice at 8-2 and 13-7, and by as little as one run at 8-7.

BOLD finished the 2012 season at 17-8 setting team records in wins, hits(216) and ERA(2.60).